We offer tailored strategies for moving in, up, or on.

Mutchmore Bergmann Realty offers a powerful & unique combination. Two highly successful, experienced Realtors with extensive corporate career backgrounds. Described as extremely professional business women, by both peers and clients alike. They bring a positive attitude and spirit to the process and look forward to Teaming up with you to achieve your Real Estate Goals and Dreams!

Serving your Buying and Selling needs 

Zionsville

•

Brownsburg

•

Carmel

•

Westfield

•

Fishers

•

Noblesville

•

Indianapolis

•

Fountain Square

•

Irvington

•

Broad Ripple

•

Meridian Kessler

•

Butler Tarkington

•

Avon

•

Lake Wawasee

•

Brown County

•

Center Grove

•

Lebanon

•

Sheridian

•

Zionsville • Brownsburg • Carmel • Westfield • Fishers • Noblesville • Indianapolis • Fountain Square • Irvington • Broad Ripple • Meridian Kessler • Butler Tarkington • Avon • Lake Wawasee • Brown County • Center Grove • Lebanon • Sheridian •

Listings

Mutchmore Bergmann Realty

Nancy and Louise

  • Nancy and Louise have a combined total of 38 years of experience and have successfully SOLD 1,000+ homes for their clients as well as extensive backgrounds in new builds. Understanding of the nuances in the expansive area served including the Greater Indianapolis & Central Indiana Marketplace in all price points, including Luxury Real Estate.

  • From the initial meeting Nancy and Louise take the time to understand your goals - providing services such as Staging and Editing, a specialized process to enhance your property to make the best possible impression on a Buyer... And you may choose to work together with both Nancy and Louise or individually, offering a personalized approach to fit your unique needs.

  • Nancy and Louise are dedicated to their collective and individual clients, striving for long term working relationships.  Expertly guiding you through every stage of the Real Estate process, as your trusted confidants and advisor they are with you every step of the way! And as often requested & needed you can be connected with tradespeople to provide various areas of expertise. 

Meet Nancy

With keen business insight and a consultative approach to real estate, Nancy Mutchmore brings a customized system to each of her clients. Nancy delivers high-touch service, unmatched creativity, and relentless advocacy for buyers and sellers. Her client-focused perspective and market knowledge has established Nancy’s reputation as one of the nation’s top realtors over her 23 year career. Whether you’re moving in, moving up, or moving on, Nancy will craft a strategy to help you and your family find your perfect home.

Nancy Pic

  • I’m a Butler grad, and before my career in real estate I worked in sales for Procter and Gamble for 17 years. Raised in Washington Township, and have lived in Hamilton County for three decades where my husband and I raised our two children here.

  • Indianapolis Business Journal Top Agent (IBJ) since 2007 consistently ranked in the top 5 Agents in the Indianapolis Area

    Berkshire Hathaway Chairman’s Gold Club – 2010-2020 – Award for top 1% of Realtors in Berkshire Hathaway

    Number #1 Agent in Berkshire Hathaway 2014, 2019 & 2020

    FC Tucker Platinum – Presidents Award – 2021- 2022 – Award for top 1% of Realtors at FC Tucker

    Realtor of the Year Nominee for Metropolitan Board of Realtors (MIBOR) – 2022

    Nominee for FC “Bud” Tucker Community Service Award for MIBOR – 2022

    Regional Vice President Berkshire Hathaway – 2014-2019

    Top 100 Century 21 Agents in the Unites States, 2008-2010

    Centurion Award - Century 21 Top Producer award - 2005-2010

    Pulte Builders Preferred Realtor Award - 2005-2008 & 2010 (after 2010, Pulte dis-continued this award)

    Century 21 Quality Service Award - 2004-2010

    Kappa Kappa Gamma Fraternity

  • Butler University - Kappa Kappa Gamma Advisory & House Board

    Board Member - Leukemia & Lymphoma Society

    Providence Cristo Rey - Intern program - 2015

  • Realtor Foundation Board :

    2017 - 2023

    Past President – 2023

    President – 2022

    Secretary – 2021

    Overdose Lifeline Board:

    2017- Current

    Secretary 2019- Current

    Relocation Specialist - CMRS, CMMS

    Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors

    National Association of Realtors

    Pulte Advisory Board

    Centex Advisory Board

  • Butler University – Bachelor of Science

Cell: (317) 459-8816

Meet Louise

Louise delivers a proven track record as an Award Winning | Multi Million Dollar Producer with 16 years experience. Most recently partnering to launch MUTCHMORE BERGMANN REALTY at FC Tucker Company. A native of Alabama, she is proud to call Indiana home since 2007, after living abroad in Argentina and almost every region of the United States. Thrilled to have reared her only daughter, Katherine and fur babies close to family in Zionsville.

  • Prior to Real Estate, Louise enjoyed a successful career for 13 years in National, Regional and Local Magazine Advertising Sales and Management, including Martha Stewart Living Magazine.

    The Central Indiana Real Estate Market continues to be an ever changing and Louise is excited to work as your trusted advisor and achieve your Real Estate goals!

    Buying or Selling a home is traditionally your largest financial investment and Louise offers exceptional attention to detail and determination during the entire process. Louise is an excellent listener and will handle all the research to help you make the best decisions when buying or selling your home.

  • National Association of REALTORS ®

    Indiana Association of REALTORS ®

    Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS ®

    Realtor Foundation: Marketing and Donor Cultivation Committee

    Kappa Alpha Theta Fraternity

    St. Alphonsus Liguroi Catholic Church

  • Buenos Aires International Newcomers Club; past President - Buenos Aires, Argentina

    Parent Teacher Organization; Board of Directors, Vice President; Asociacion Escuelas Lincoln - Buenos Aires, Argentina

    Conservancy/Scenic Corridor Committee - Long Grove, IL

    Julian Center Fundraising Committee - Indianapolis, IN

  • Graduate, University of Alabama; BA Communications

    Graduate, Real Estate Certification Program

    Graduate, Professional Sales Academy, Tucker University

Cell: (317) 332-2046

Email: louise.bergmann@talktotucker.com

  • Susie

    Buyers & Sellers, Multiple Properties

    “Nancy is our family REALTOR. She has worked with all of our children to buy and sell their homes. She was wonderful and made our transition to Carmel very easy. We know she will take great care of our children too!”

  • Jan

    Buyer

    “I purchased my Zionsville Village home in mid-April and wasn't able to move in until mid-June. Louise was an excellent advocate through the negotiation process and then continued to assist me post-purchase in a variety of ways.”

  • Tom

    Sellers

    “We love Nancy. She is our forever Realtor! She made a very tough transaction look easy. She took care of managing all the inspection repairs with her contractors. She took care of all the details and we focused on packing.”

  • Dr. Sakthi & Rose M.

    Buyers & Sellers

    “From our first conversation, my wife and I knew Louise Bergmann would be our greatest resource to build our home. Without her continuous counsel and support we would have struggled much harder to build our dream home.”

  • Jenny & John

    Sellers

    “I can’t begin to explain all that Nancy did for my family. We had to downsize my mom’s house to something manageable for her as she is getting older. Nancy was incredibly resourceful and organized and helped us through this process.”

  • Rachel and Mike

    Sellers

    “Louise's experience and confidence in the real estate world was evident from the first phone call to closing and every single minute in between. She clearly guided us through each step with detailed explanations and readiness to answer all the questions.”

  • Joan

    Buyers & Sellers, Multiple Properties

    “We have bought and sold 7 homes with Nancy. She is amazing! We have recommended her to many of our friends too. She goes above and beyond and makes it a seamless transaction for us.”

  • Guinn and Marianne

    Buyers & Sellers

    “Louise Sold our home Historic home on Pine Street, in the village of Zionsville. Louise's wealth of knowledge and experience in the Village real estate market made the sale of our home a positive experience.”

  • Alex & Chelsea

    Buyers and Sellers, Multiple Properties

    “We have luckily had multiple opportunities to work with Louise. She has helped us purchase homes, as well as helped us sell our homes. We wouldn't want to go through the process without having her on our side.”

  • Catherine

    Buyers & Sellers, Multiple Properties

    “Louise is the Realtor I rave about! She works tirelessly to find the perfect properties that align with your wants and needs, explains data sheets like a champ, and expertly guides you through every step of the Buying/Selling process.”